baby doing tummy time with pacifier nearby

The 5 Best Pacifier Alternatives for Your Baby that Might Surprise You!

There’s no doubt that pacifiers are a life-saver for many parents. Babies need comforting items and objects to help them feel secure and happy. And when it comes to soothing babies, pacifiers seem to be the go-to items. But what if you don’t want to use one? Or what if your baby doesn’t like pacifiers?

If you’re looking for the best pacifier alternative, you’re in luck! In this blog post, we’ll discuss some of the best alternatives to pacifiers. We’ll also provide tips on how to transition your baby from using a pacifier to one of these alternatives.

Whether you’re looking for something that will help soothe your baby or simply want to phase out pacifiers, read on for insights and advice.

This post contains affiliate links, which means I receive a small commission, at no extra cost to you, if you make a purchase using this link. Please see my disclosure for more details.

Why Would You Need an Alternative to Pacifiers?

Before we discuss the best pacifier alternatives, let’s first talk about why you might need or want to use one. As stated above, pacifiers are great for soothing and comforting babies. But they’re not the only option out there.

There are a few reasons you might want to consider using an alternative to pacifiers. First, some babies simply don’t like pacifiers. They may spit them out or refuse to use them. If this is the case with your baby, it’s probably best to try another option.

Second, you may be looking to phase out the use of pacifiers altogether. This is completely understandable! Many parents want to wean their babies off of pacifiers before their first birthday. And while this isn’t always an easy task, it is possible.

baby holding blue pacifier

If you’re hoping to transition your baby from using a pacifier to not using one at all, then an alternative may be a good option for you. This way, your baby can still have something to soothe and comfort them. But at the same time, you can begin to wean them off of the pacifier.

Finally, some parents prefer not to use pacifiers. Maybe you’ve heard horror stories about babies who become attached to their pacifiers. Or maybe you’re not comfortable with the idea of using one.

Whatever the reason, if you’re not interested in using a pacifier, that’s totally fine! There are plenty of other options out there for soothing and comforting babies.

The Best Alternatives to Pacifiers

Now that we’ve discussed the reasons you might want to use a pacifier alternative, let’s talk about the best options. Below, we’ve listed some of the top pacifier alternatives for you to consider.

Teething Toys

Teething toys are a great option for babies who are teething (obvi). They can help relieve some of the pain and discomfort that comes with teething. Plus, they can keep baby occupied and distracted from the pain. Some good teething toy options include:

  • Teether keys – These fun keys feature various textures that help soothe sore gums. They also make a fun rattling sound when shaken.
  • Textured silicone rings – These soft rings have a variety of bumps, nubs, and ridges that provide relief for teething gums.
  • Soft fabric books – Babies love exploring new textures, and soft fabric books offer plenty of different fabrics to touch and feel. Plus, they’re lightweight and easy for little hands to hold.
baby holding wooden teething ring

White Noise

White noise can be very calming and soothing for babies. It can help them fall asleep and stay asleep. Many white noise machines on the market offer a variety of sounds, such as:

  • The sound of a fan
  • The sound of rain
  • The sound of waves
  • The sound of a heartbeat

Our favorite white noise machine is also an okay-to-wake night light, the Hatch. This sound machine will keep your child dreaming with sounds playing softly in the background. These include sounds such as white noise, wind, or rain.

The soothing night light reassures your little one and makes midnight feedings calming. The Time-to-Rise feature lets early risers know when it’s time to start their day by gradually increasing both the light and sound over time.

Hatch Rest Baby Sound Machine, Night Light | 2nd Gen | Sleep Trainer, Time-to-Rise Alarm Clock, White Noise Soother, Music & Stories for Nursery, Toddler & Kids Bedroom (Wi-Fi)
  • Our latest, updated Rest 2nd gen sound machine is now Wi-Fi enabled, with dimmable clock and even more features for dreamy sleep!
  • Sound Machine. Includes soothing sounds like white noise, ocean, wind, fan, heartbeat, rain, and lullabies. Expand your library with the Hatch Sleep Membership, an optional add-on library of bedtime stories, classic music tunes, and more expert curated sleep content. Free trial included.
  • Smart Night Light. Fun, bedside lamp with infinite custom color hues. Perfect for boys or girls. Illuminate the crib and changing table to ease nighttime infant feedings. Make the dark less scary in your child’s room with a calming glow.
  • Time-to-Rise & Time-for-Bed. Program color and sound to let your early riser know when to stay in bed and when it’s ok to wake up. Build a routine to train your little one to wind down for naps and bedtime.
  • Control via app from anywhere. Adjust settings and set timers remotely with smartphone, or control volume and nightlight by touch with easy-access buttons on the device.

Night Light

Speaking of night lights, they can be very helpful for both babies and parents. They can help babies feel more comfortable in the dark and make nighttime feedings and diaper changes easier. There are many different types of night lights on the market, such as:

baby holding nightlight in nursery

A Security Blanket or Transitional Object

A security blanket or lovey is another great alternative to a pacifier. It can provide baby with a sense of security and comfort. It’s something that they can hold on to and cuddle with. And it can be a great transitional object when it’s time to wean off of the pacifier.

A New Toy

A new toy can also be a great way to soothe baby. It can provide them with a distraction while weaning from the pacifier. And it’s a fun way to help them explore their senses. Some good toy options include:

  • A stuffed animal
  • A soft toy
  • A set of colorful stacking blocks
  • A baby gym
toddler holding stuffed animal

Weaning Pacifier Systems

If you’re looking for a way to wean your baby off of the pacifier, many products on the market can help. These weaning pacifier sets come with several different-sized pacifiers. They start with a full-sized pacifier and gradually get smaller. This helps baby get used to using a smaller pacifier and eventually not using one at all.

You can also gradually cut your current pacifiers down to size. This is done with a pair of scissors or a sharp knife. Start by cutting off a small piece of the tip of the pacifier. If this doesn’t seem to bother your baby, then cut off a little bit more each day until the pacifier is gone.

Frida Baby Paci Weaning System
  • PATENTED 5 STEP SYSTEM: Gradually reduces sucking satisfaction to wean from orthodontic nipple.
  • DENTIST DESIGNED: Invented by a pediatric dentist.
  • BOOT THE BINKY: Golden ticket for kiddos between 6-18 months. Beyond that, the harder it gets.
  • BPA-FREE: Latex-free and BPA-free. Silicone nipples.
  • WHATS INSIDE?  5 orthodontic-shaped dentist-designed pacifiers that get shorter with each step

The Process of Weaning Pacifiers

Why is weaning pacifiers important?

The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) recommends that parents wean their baby off of the pacifier by the time they reach 6 months old. This is because prolonged use of a pacifier can lead to dental problems, such as an overbite or open bite, and even speech delays. Pacifier use can also cause ear infections

How to Start Weaning Pacifiers

Weaning pacifiers can be a difficult process for both babies and parents. But there are a few things that you can do to make it a little easier. First, try gradually reducing the amount of time that your baby uses the pacifier. Second, try only giving the pacifier during certain times of the day, such as bedtime or naptime. And third, offer other comforting items and objects to your baby, such as a security blanket or lovey.

And give yourself some grace. Weaning is a process and it may take some time. But eventually, you and your baby will be pacifier-free!

Is a pacifier alternative right for you and your baby?

There are many different reasons to need an alternative to a pacifier. Lucky for us moms, there are many different types of pacifier alternatives on the market. From toys to night lights, there’s sure to be an option that’s perfect for your little one. And if one doesn’t work, try another one!

What’s your favorite pacifier alternative? Let us know in the comments below!

Check out these other articles on newborns!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *