guests at a baby shower celebrating mom-to-be and feeling pregnant belly

Baby Shower Game Prizes: How to Choose the Perfect Gift for Your Guests

If you’re hosting a baby shower soon and find yourself in a last-minute scramble to find the perfect prizes for your games, don’t worry – we’ve got you covered. We understand that there are many aspects to consider when planning a baby shower – from the theme to the decorations.  And then you have to worry if you are hosting a display baby shower and helping mom decide what to wear! So sometimes the prizes can be overlooked until the eleventh hour.

But fear not! In this blog post, we’ll help you navigate the process of choosing the ideal game prizes for your guests. Whether you’re working with a specific theme, a tight budget, or a diverse guest list, we have plenty of ideas to inspire you. So let’s dive in and make sure your baby shower games are not only entertaining but also leave your guests feeling appreciated and delighted with their prizes!

This post contains affiliate links, which means I receive a small commission, at no extra cost to you, if you make a purchase using this link. Please see my disclosure for more details.

Things to Consider When Choosing Baby Shower Game Prizes

Baby Shower Theme

When selecting prizes for your baby shower games, start by considering the theme of the event. Aligning the prizes with the overall theme helps create a cohesive experience. For example, if your baby shower has a “Cute Creatures” theme, you might choose animal-themed gifts. This could include stuffed animals or animal-shaped soaps as prizes.

Budget Considerations

Before purchasing prizes, it’s crucial to establish your budget. You don’t need to break the bank to provide memorable and fun rewards to your guests. Think creatively and consider purchasing items in bulk or crafting your own DIY prize ideas. Inexpensive yet thoughtful prizes, such as cute tumblers with drink mix packets can be a hit, as suggested on Another Mommy Blogger.

Guest List

Keep your guest list in mind when choosing prizes. Opt for items that will appeal to a wide range of recipients since people have different tastes and preferences. You can personalize the prizes to make them more special or choose universally appreciated gifts, such as:

  • Scented candles
  • Succulents or small plants
  • Gourmet chocolates
  • Coffee or tea sets
  • Wine stoppers

The key is to select prizes that are relevant, budget-friendly, and in line with the baby shower theme. But you should also take into consideration the preferences of your guest list. Remember to have fun with your choices and get creative!

guests at a baby shower holding up decorated cookies as game prizes and celebrating mom-to-be

Popular Baby Shower Game Prize Ideas

Gift Cards

Gift cards are always a hit for baby shower game prizes. Offer gift cards to popular stores, restaurants, or entertainment venues. Some favorite options include Starbucks, Target, Amazon, Walmart, Netflix, Hulu, Disney, and Fandango.


Brighten up your guests’ homes with succulents or small plants as prizes. These make thoughtful and eco-friendly choices that many people will appreciate. You can even make a tag that says “Thank you for helping me grow!” to stay on the theme of a baby shower.


Everyone loves chocolate! Offer chocolate sets or candy bars as delicious and affordable game prizes. Consider creating a basket with different types of chocolates. Or choose individually wrapped candies that are easy to take home and enjoy!

Bath Products

Pamper your guests with bath products as prizes. Items like bath bombs, sugar scrubs, or body washes make excellent baby shower game prizes that guests can enjoy at home.


Uncork some fun by offering bottles of wine as prizes. A well-selected bottle will be appreciated by many guests. For extra credit, you can even choose a special label in honor of the baby shower.

Kitchen Items

Make your guests feel at home with practical and stylish kitchen items such as wine glasses, coffee mugs, or tea cups. Personalized tumblers or custom-scented candles can also be a great option from Etsy.

Lottery Tickets

Give your guests a chance to hit the jackpot with lottery tickets as baby shower game prizes. It’s an exciting and inexpensive option that’ll keep the fun going long after the event!

Body Care Items

Treat your guests to luxurious body care items like lotions, lip balm sets, and essential oils. These products can provide relaxation and self-care, making them a popular choice for many guests.

Edible Treats

Finally, satisfy your guests’ sweet tooth with edible treats like cupcakes, cookies, or popcorn. A movie night gift basket, cookie mix in a jar, or even a sangria kit are other unique options that can delight your guests.

Remember to choose prizes that cater to your guests’ interests, and don’t be afraid to get creative. By offering a variety of exciting and thoughtful rewards, you’ll make your baby shower games even more engaging and memorable.

Economical and Easy Baby Shower Game Prizes

DIY Prizes

Creating your own baby shower game prizes can be a fun and economical way to show your appreciation to your guests. For instance, you can put together simple and personalized gift sets using items like lip balms or nail files. You can also create small pampering kits that include items like dish towels or washcloths, perfect for a relaxing spa day at home. This will not only save you money but also demonstrate your thoughtfulness and gratitude in giving out prizes.

Dollar Store Finds

Dollar stores can be a treasure trove for finding inexpensive yet delightful baby shower game prizes. Here are a few great ideas for prizes that you can find at your local dollar store:

  • Mini picture frames: A sweet keepsake for your guests to remember the special day.
  • Scented candles: A fragrant prize that can be enjoyed at home.
  • Coasters: Practical and pretty, a wonderful addition to any home.

Baked Goods

If you love to bake, consider making cookies or other baked goods as baby shower game prizes. Not only are these a delicious treat but they can also be presented cutely and attractively. Try arranging your goodies in decorative bags, jars, or boxes for a little extra flair. Baking your own prizes is a heartwarming way to thank your guests for their participation, while also providing them with a tasty reward.

Unique and Creative Baby Shower Game Prizes

Personalized Items

One great idea for baby shower game prizes is to offer personalized gifts. These can make your guests feel special and appreciated. Some fantastic options include personalized candles, personalized photo frames, and even customized wine glasses or coffee cups for guests to remember the special day.

Handcrafted Items

Do you have a knack for crafting? Consider creating personalized items like custom-made candles with scents that match the baby shower theme. You can also make handmade soap bars in delightful shapes or personalized bath bomb sets.

If you have a talent for baking or cooking, consider making homemade jams, cookies, or other treats. Package them in cute jars or boxes with personalized labels or ribbons. Not only will these delicious goodies make great prizes, but they will also be a sweet reminder of the baby shower long after the event.

Handcrafted items provide a personal touch and can truly make your baby shower game prizes stand out. Your guests will appreciate the effort and love put into creating these one-of-a-kind treasures.

So unleash your creativity, explore various crafting ideas, and let your imagination run wild as you handcraft prizes that will leave a lasting impression on your guests.

Green and Eco-friendly Prizes

Incorporate a green and eco-friendly theme into your baby shower game prizes to show your commitment to protecting the planet. Some eco-conscious prize ideas include:

  • Reusable items like silicone food storage bags, beeswax wraps, and stainless steel straws.
  • Organic health and beauty items such as lip gloss, shampoo bars, and bamboo toothbrushes.
  • Biodegradable options such as gum, mints, hair clips, and hair ties.
guests participating in a baby shower game of guess the baby food in order to win baby shower game prizes

Final Thoughts on Baby Shower Game Prizes

As you wrap up the planning for your baby shower, don’t forget about the game prizes! They may seem like a small detail, but they can make a big impact on your guests’ experience. By considering the theme of your baby shower, setting a budget, and keeping your guest list in mind, you can choose prizes that will be both relevant and enjoyable for everyone.

From gift cards and plants to bath products and edible treats, there are so many fun and creative options to explore. And if you’re looking for economical choices, DIY prizes, and dollar store finds can be just as delightful.

Remember, personalized items, handcrafted treasures, and eco-friendly prizes can add an extra touch of thoughtfulness to the occasion. So go ahead and get creative with your baby shower game prizes! You’re not only making the games more engaging but also leaving your guests with a lasting token of appreciation. Your baby shower is sure to be a memorable event filled with laughter, joy, and happy guests. Enjoy every moment of it!

Baby Shower Game Prizes Pin 2

Similar Posts